I can finally say that I’m perfectly content leaving behind Brakebills, Fillory and the Neitherlands and I feel some satisfaction that Quentin finally feels like he is home.
If you haven’t read this series and you are craving a good fantasy, a good love story, a good adventure – this is your series. It’s one that I am sure I’ll be coming back to over the years. Read more of this review at Notes in the Margin.
This book definitely falls more into the middle-grade territory than into young adult - but even so, I was not as impressed with it as I hoped to be. I found myself felling a resounding "meh" throughout the course of the novel. Clearly a re-imagining of the classic The Jungle Book where we trade the jungle for a graveyard and the wolf pack for ghosts.
So strange how as I grow older, these stories have different effects on me. I found some of Dumbledore's behavior a little more than frustrating this time around. And feel less and less pity for Snape. Malfoy's story, however, left me feeling quite sad - he is such a product of his circumstances and a pawn in the grand scheme of everything. (July, 2014)
I can tell that I’ve just scraped the tip off of the massive iceberg that is A Song of Ice and Fire, and I am both excited and terrified for what may come next.
Overall it was a nice story, but lacking in likable characters and forward momentum. Read the rest of this review at Notes in the Margin.
Every time I get to the end of a series, there is a familiar silence and weight that I feel. Now I have to let these characters go, and this time I really don’t want to.
Overall I wouldn’t classify it as a must read. It took me a while to get into and the main character is charming but ultimately problematic. However, the heart of the story will touch you and give you a nostalgic feeling in the pit of your stomach.
This novel holds nothing back, and I should warn you not to get too attached to anyone. You will be surprised at how quick Higson is to rip characters from the pages of this book and it's best just to accept their fate and move along. Read the rest of this review at Notes in the Margin.
This is a beautiful book about self-acceptance, falling in love and letting go. And it does such an amazing job of it, I really can't say it enough. Read it.